The Perfect Fit: A stand-alone why choose romance

4.4 out of 5

22,934 global ratings

A Dark Why Choose Romance.

One wannabe writer from Brooklyn.

Three insanely hot billionaires.

One very indecent proposal.

West Archer, Ezekiel Cavanagh, and Xander King. AKA The Unholy Trinity. Ruthless. Ambitious. Intimidating.

With dark tastes and even darker desires, they’ve been searching for the perfect woman to fit into their unique lifestyle for over a decade. But despite their best efforts, none have made it past three months. Believing they’re destined to never find the one, they swear to stop looking.

Until they meet Lily.

There’s something about Lily Sloane, something that captivates all three of them. For the first time ever, it seems like they may have truly found the perfect fit. But as we all know, there is such a thing as too good to be true.

Lily Sloane isn’t the penniless girl from Brooklyn they think she is. And with a past full of secrets and lies that she’s trying to escape, the unholy trinity might have bitten off more than they can chew. When trust is broken, is there any way back?

The Perfect Fit is a dark why-choose MMFM romance with lots of angst, emotion, betrayal, and enough heat to melt your kindle. This book contains grumpy/sunshine, sword crossing, an epic grovel, and a HEA.

Content warnings include: CNC, knife play, blood play, primal play.

418 pages,

Kindle

Audiobook

Paperback

First published December 4, 2023

ISBN 9781915663306


About the authors

Sadie Kincaid

Sadie Kincaid

Sadie Kincaid is an Amazon No1 bestselling spicy romance author. She lives in the UK with her husband, sons and her very cute, dog.

Sadie writes feisty heroines and morally grey, swoon-worthy alphas with filthy mouths, who would burn the world down for the ladies they love.

Join Sadie's Facebook reader group: Sadie's Ladies and Sizzling Alphas


Reviews

Aryn

Aryn

5

fast paced with the right amount of spice

Reviewed in the United States on December 12, 2023

Verified Purchase

Sadie Kincaid's latest standalone novel, "The Perfect Fit," is a captivating exploration of love, choices, and self-discovery in why choose romance. With a solid 4.5-star rating and a spice level of 3.5, this novel effortlessly weaves together a compelling plot, excellent character development, and a dash of unexpected twists that leave readers yearning for more.

One of the standout features of "The Perfect Fit" is the impeccable character development. Kincaid intricately crafts the journey of four main characters – Zeke, West, Xander, and Lily – as they navigate the complex terrain of love and relationships. Each character undergoes significant growth throughout the novel, making them relatable and endearing to readers.

Zeke, the brooding bad boy with a mysterious past, is a character that will undoubtedly capture the hearts of readers. Kincaid skillfully peels back the layers of Zeke's persona, revealing a depth and vulnerability that adds a rich texture to the story. As he grapples with his demons, readers will cheer for Zeke's redemption and newfound happiness.

West, the charming and intense "leader," provides a delightful contrast to Zeke's intensity. The evolution of West's character is a joy to witness, as he discovers the true meaning of love and commitment. Kincaid adeptly explores the dynamics of his relationships, creating a character arc that is both satisfying and heartwarming.

Xander, the golden retriever with a heart of gold, adds another layer of complexity to the narrative. His introspective journey into the intricacies of love and desire is thought-provoking and emotionally resonant. Readers will appreciate the authenticity of Xander's character as he confronts his faults and insecurities.

Lily, the story's central character, is a strong and independent woman navigating the challenges of multiple romantic interests and a dark past. Kincaid masterfully portrays Lily's internal struggles, creating a nuanced and empowering portrayal of a woman unapologetically exploring her desires and choices.

The novel's plot is well-crafted and engaging, with Kincaid skillfully balancing the romantic elements with unexpected twists. The author's ability to keep readers on the edge of their seats while delivering a satisfying and emotionally resonant resolution is commendable. The plot twists, in particular, are a highlight, injecting a dose of unpredictability that elevates the story to new heights.

The spice level in "The Perfect Fit" is a solid 3.5, adding an irresistible edge to the romance without overshadowing the emotional depth of the characters. Kincaid tastefully weaves intimate moments into the narrative, enhancing the connection between the characters without resorting to gratuitous scenes.

The only minor drawback is the desire for more; the plot twists leave readers hungry for additional chapters that explore the aftermath of the revelations. This craving for more is a testament to Kincaid's ability to create a world and characters that readers invest in and care deeply about.

"The Perfect Fit" by Sadie Kincaid is a standout standalone why choose romance that ticks all the boxes. With exceptional character development, a well-crafted plot, and a satisfying spice level, this novel is a must-read for fans of the genre. Kincaid's storytelling prowess is on full display, making "The Perfect Fit" a delightful and memorable addition to the world of contemporary romance.

Read more

65 people found this helpful

Connie

Connie

5

Great Book

Reviewed in the United States on December 10, 2023

Verified Purchase

Holy crap, this book was… I don't even have the words to describe how I feel about this book. Good isn't the right word. Great seems not to be the right fit. Amazingly perfect now that's the perfect fit. Lily, West, Zeke, and Xander really are the perfect fit for each other. This book is filled with a lot of emotions. It will have you laughing, crying, swooning, smiling, frowning, scowling, and even make you a bit angry, at least for me it did. I really didn't like the miscommunication in this book but that's okay because the guys more than made up for it. 

Lily is sweet, yet you know there is more than meets the eye about her. Zeke is so dominant and boy oh boy does he pull it off very well. He is definitely a top. West is also very dominant and while he pulls it off he is so sweet and loving. Xander is a bottom and a brat but man did I love him. I really connected well with Xander because well I can also be a bit of a brat. I really loved all of the characters in this book and it really was a wonderful read. I honestly haven't read any MM romances and the MMF ones I have read there weren't much MM other than kissing and maybe a little fooling around but nothing like this book. There was so much MM action happening in this book that it pulled me into another world and I'm so thankful for that. This book is a great way to explore somethings you have been thinking about reading but not entirely sure you want to read a full story about. Dom/sub, MM, MMF, MMMF. MF it has it all. There is something for everyone in this book with a wide variety of kinks as well, for example one of my favorites primal.  

I think that it is no surprise that I loved this book as much as I did. I think we all know Sadie is one of my favorite authors. She is so kind and caring, and she writes so incredibly well. Honestly I can not say how good her writing style is. She gives such great descriptions and really pulls you into the story. There is great character development, a few secrets, and a whole lot of spice. She gives the characters great chemistry, tension, and makes sure that once you pick up a book by her that you don't want to and can't put it down.

Read more

24 people found this helpful

Brandie

Brandie

5

WOW! I could not put this book down!!!!!!

Reviewed in the United States on May 29, 2024

Verified Purchase

Be advised that this may spoil some parts of the book for some.

Sooo I've never read a book where the male characters not only share one female but also share each other. when that first happened, I was like wait wait wait because I was aware of the sharing one female but wasn't aware the men would also be into each other. At first that whole part threw me off and i was like umm what am I reading but I powered through it and Little did I know I would really enjoy this story as a whole. I was pretty surprised at how much I enjoyed this book. In no way am i homophobic or anything of the sort. its just that ive never read anything like this. So if you don't think you can handle men being with men, please be advised that there is a handful of scenes where men are with men.

The story is well written, it's my first read from this author and I can honestly say I love the way she writes and how engaging the story was. I could not put this book down. I finished the book in under 48 hours! The story itself keeps you hooked in with the many different things happening. it was easy to follow even though there were so many different characters. The characters are so divers and have different things about them that you will love. I've already recommended this book to a friend and now Shes hooked on it too!

Read more

5 people found this helpful

Renee

Renee

5

10/10

Reviewed in the United States on June 28, 2024

Verified Purchase

I'm not usually into the polyamorous tropes, however this one had great story was very well put together and the characters are just phenomenal.

I love how the characters just flowed together, the amount of spice and smut was perfect. Xander was absolutely hilarious I love how he was the comic relief and for the most part was the calm sensible one. Cack made me laugh so hard I cried, you have to read it to find out.

I highly recommend this book!!

Read more

eric melton

eric melton

5

Why did she have to kill him??

Reviewed in the United States on July 23, 2024

Verified Purchase

THIS!! Don't read this book on a 2 hour flight to Chicago!! You will be squirming and panting the whole flight. I loved the change of pace reading a totally different scenario and setting. That was very unexpected. I hate to say there were too many s*x scenes because I know that is why I'm reading it, but..for a longer book, I wish there were more character depth. Maybe a chapter on each personal relationship? This is the second book I've read by Kincaid, and I already have the rest downloaded on my Fire. I have 2 Kindles just in case 1 of them dies before I finish the book. That's the worst! I would suggest this book to everyone, except my ladies prayer group. I mean, I loved it, and I'm in the group too! 😄😇

Read more

Satchel Paige

Satchel Paige

5

Melty goodness!!

Reviewed in the United States on July 19, 2024

Verified Purchase

Whew this book was fire!!! I love a good why choose and this one had all the elements I can’t get enough of: growly alphaholes, feisty FMC, group activities, relationships within the group to include MF and MM, swoony moments, k!nks, heartbreak, mystery, and all the smu++y deliciousness!

I did combo read/audio for this book and it was one of the best audios I’ve heard! It’s duet narrated by 4 amazing artists, all of which will be added to my list of top narrators!

West, Xander, Zeke are best friends who own a media conglomerate and have a tight relationship with each other. They like to partake in a contracted partnership with a female, and the last ones have just not measured up.

Lily has a past full of secrets and when she delivers mail to WXZ has a “meet cute” with Zeke and Xander before coming face to face with West after 14 years, though he doesn’t know her or how she knows him. A night at the club and too much champagne later leads her to becoming the Unholy Trinity’s next partner.

Little did any of them know how fast and hard they would all fall for each other over the next several months. Lily is exactly what each of them need and they realize how perfect she is. How she sees the real them, the dark and twisty, the hurt and comfort, the way the guys love one another but also her with every fiber of their being.

When things get a little rocky and secrets threaten to tear them apart, I felt every bit of their heartbreak and cried along with Lily. I felt all the rage she had after the Unholy Trinity shut her out, and I couldn’t get enough of the makeup after the groveling! I absolutely loved the dynamics of the four of them together and this book has some of the best smexy scenes!!

I loved the balance of spice and plot too. There were plenty of oh crap moments and surprises along the way! I completely devoured this book and left no crumbs!! Highly recommend!!

Read more

Erica B

Erica B

5

I loved this!

Reviewed in the United States on June 21, 2024

Verified Purchase

Wow. I absolutely devoured this book and audio. This was so freaking good. This was my first Sadie Kincaid book, so I wasn’t sure what to expect… but Wow.. It was incredible. I can’t wait to read more from her.

I absolutely loved all the MC’s- Lily, West, Xander, & Zeke. Every single character was so well thought out. And I loved every single one for different reasons.

The audio for this book was amazing. The voices fit each character’s personality so well and added so much to this story. Lily’s emotion, West’s growls and deep voice, Xanders sweet, understanding tone, and Zeke’s deep, dangerous voice. I loved them all. This audio was one of the best I’ve heard.

I’m not going to lie… I was so pissed at the MMC’s at one point. (Like why?!? Over freaking puppies??!!!) But they quickly redeem themselves. But stick with it… It’s such a good HEA!

I loved this book couldn’t put it down, but I also never wanted it to end. If you are looking for a why choose, with lots of spice & kinks ⚔️, but also has some twists and a plot… then this one is for you.

Read more

Risa Lynn

Risa Lynn

4

Fast and hot!

Reviewed in the United States on January 11, 2024

Verified Purchase

The Perfect Fit was pretty good! It’s definitely a fast burn, which I loved, and the spice is quite abundant, but there’s an intriguing storyline underneath all the spice.

Lily is sweet and kind of shy at first, which is understandable because the guys sound intimidatingly hot! Hahaha. Xander is adorable. He’s like a little excitable puppy dog, which was cute. West is grumpy but pretty cocky — for good reason. Zeke is grumpy, too, but sooo sweet once he lets Lily in.

I will say I was kinda disappointed with what turned out to be Zeke’s s3xual interests. They made such a big deal about it in the beginning, but it really didn’t turn out to be anything super crazy. I don’t know. Maybe I just read dark romance or more intense things, but I was just expecting more from the fuss they all made.

Overall, though, it was a really good book! I give it 4/5 stars and 4.5/5 spice!

Read more

16 people found this helpful

BigDDs_BookCorner

BigDDs_BookCorner

4

Sadie Does It Again

Reviewed in the United States on July 5, 2024

Verified Purchase

I had to run to read this book after hearing all the hype about the delights found in this book. Yes, this is a foursome, and every page is delicious.

I loved the characters and their emotional connection with each other. Lily is a fantastic female lead who I loved every minute of. And let's be real, Sadie knows how to create fabulous dominant men that you want to be a brat for.

I loved the dynamic between Zeke, Xander, and West. The push and pull between these three was wonderful, and I just couldn't get enough of them. The twists and turns within the story were wonderful and kept the story moving. It was fast-paced, and all the action I've come to expect from Sadie's writing.

Another book I'll be recommending this year. I love this author, and she just doesn't disappoint.

Read more

2 people found this helpful

Ashley

Ashley

3

The Perfect Fit...

Reviewed in the United States on June 9, 2024

Verified Purchase

3.5 stars, two things kept me from selecting a full 4.

One, this book was probably 70-75 percent spice and 25-30 percent storyline. While I felt the spice was very well written, I wished there was more development of the relationship or the main characters lives.

Two, the ending/epilogue was basically just another spice scene, and It bums me out a bit when the author chooses to use that to add another scene, rather than any real development of their relationship and lives.

I genuinely enjoyed the emotional highs and lows. I definitely teared up at some parts and laughed at others. The fmc was a badass in the sense, she wasn't a doll eyed pushover. She was sweet and intelligent but held her ground and pushed back when needed.

Of the men, Zeke was my favorite. All three played their roles well and the relationship was well rounded and had easy flow.

This book is also HEAVY on the M/M spice, so if your not into that then I'd avoid.

Overall a good read and I'd recommend.

Read more

5 people found this helpful